Stability Assessment on Safety of Shield Tunneling Based on Game Theory and Extension Cloud
WANG Wei1, WANG Xing1, LIU Dan-na2, ZHOU Xun3
1. School of Civil Engineering, Changchun Institute of Technology, Changchun, Jilin 130021, China; 2. Road and Bridge International Co., Ltd., Beijing 100024, China; 3. China Communication North Road and Bridge Co., Ltd., Beijing 100024, China
Stability Assessment on Safety of Shield Tunneling Based on Game Theory and Extension Cloud
WANG Wei1, WANG Xing1, LIU Dan-na2, ZHOU Xun3
1. School of Civil Engineering, Changchun Institute of Technology, Changchun, Jilin 130021, China; 2. Road and Bridge International Co., Ltd., Beijing 100024, China; 3. China Communication North Road and Bridge Co., Ltd., Beijing 100024, China
摘要During the construction of the metro shield, the surrounding ground surface and buildings will settle due to the disturbance of sand and gravel during excavation. Therefore, it is essential to evaluate the safety and stability of shield tunneling. Aiming to address the ambiguity, randomness, and significance of each index in the process of evaluating safety and stability during shield tunneling, the study utilizes a method that combines game theory and extension cloud. Monitoring data related to ground subsidence, building settlement, embankment settlement, pipeline settlement, and segment deformation are selected as evaluation indices to develop a comprehensive extension cloud evaluation model for shield tunneling safety. The model is validated using real-world engineering cases. The results show that according to the combined weight results obtained by the game theory, analytic hierarchy process, and entropy weighting method, the safety and stability evaluation indexes of the shield tunnel interval in this case are building settlement, segment deformation, ground settlement, pipeline settlement, and embankment settlement in order of importance. The safety and stability of nineteen monitoring groups are evaluated using the comprehensive extension cloud model, including eight Level III, four Level II, and seven Level I. Among them, monitoring groups at Level II and Level I nearby need to adopt corresponding preventive measures. The comprehensive evaluation model developed in this study, based on game theory and extension cloud, can reflect the uncertain relationships among various indicators. It helps to avoid the one-sidedness of single weighting. Compared with fuzzy comprehensive evaluation, the calculation results are more aligned with objective reality. Based on the aforementioned research, a comprehensive evaluation method is proposed, which combines game theory and extension cloud model. This method offers a novel approach and concept for safety evaluation in shield construction. The research can provide scientific references for the safety and stability evaluation of shield tunneling in sandy and pebble strata in the Chengdu area.
Abstract：During the construction of the metro shield, the surrounding ground surface and buildings will settle due to the disturbance of sand and gravel during excavation. Therefore, it is essential to evaluate the safety and stability of shield tunneling. Aiming to address the ambiguity, randomness, and significance of each index in the process of evaluating safety and stability during shield tunneling, the study utilizes a method that combines game theory and extension cloud. Monitoring data related to ground subsidence, building settlement, embankment settlement, pipeline settlement, and segment deformation are selected as evaluation indices to develop a comprehensive extension cloud evaluation model for shield tunneling safety. The model is validated using real-world engineering cases. The results show that according to the combined weight results obtained by the game theory, analytic hierarchy process, and entropy weighting method, the safety and stability evaluation indexes of the shield tunnel interval in this case are building settlement, segment deformation, ground settlement, pipeline settlement, and embankment settlement in order of importance. The safety and stability of nineteen monitoring groups are evaluated using the comprehensive extension cloud model, including eight Level III, four Level II, and seven Level I. Among them, monitoring groups at Level II and Level I nearby need to adopt corresponding preventive measures. The comprehensive evaluation model developed in this study, based on game theory and extension cloud, can reflect the uncertain relationships among various indicators. It helps to avoid the one-sidedness of single weighting. Compared with fuzzy comprehensive evaluation, the calculation results are more aligned with objective reality. Based on the aforementioned research, a comprehensive evaluation method is proposed, which combines game theory and extension cloud model. This method offers a novel approach and concept for safety evaluation in shield construction. The research can provide scientific references for the safety and stability evaluation of shield tunneling in sandy and pebble strata in the Chengdu area.
基金资助:This study is supported by the Science and Technology Development Plan Project of Jilin Province（No.20220203058SF）;Science and Technology R&D Project of Zhongjiao Road and Bridge Construction Co.,Ltd.(No.ZJLJ-2018-44).
通讯作者:
WANG Wei
引用本文:
WANG Wei, WANG Xing, LIU Dan-na, ZHOU Xun. Stability Assessment on Safety of Shield Tunneling Based on Game Theory and Extension Cloud[J]. Journal of Highway and Transportation Research and Development, 2024, 18(2): 34-45.
WANG Wei, WANG Xing, LIU Dan-na, ZHOU Xun. Stability Assessment on Safety of Shield Tunneling Based on Game Theory and Extension Cloud. Journal of Highway and Transportation Research and Development, 2024, 18(2): 34-45.
[1] ISAKSSON M T. Tunnelling in Poor Ground-Choice of Shield Method Based on Reliability[M]//Geotechnical Hazards. Boca Raton:CRC Press, 2020:527-534. [2] ESKESEN S D, TENGBORG P, KAMPMANN J, et al. Guidelines for Tunnelling Risk Management:International Tunnelling Association, Working Group No. 2[J]. Tunnelling and Underground Space Technology, 2004, 19(3):217-237. [3] REN Qiang. Study on Risk Evaluation and Control Technology of Shielding Construction of Beijing Underground[D]. Beijing:China University of Geosciences, 2010.(in Chinese) [4] HU Chang-ming, LU Zheng-yu, MEI Yuan, et al. On the Risk Evaluation of the Metro Shield Construction in the Soft Soil Condition Background with the Extension Method[J]. Journal of Safety and Environment, 2017, 17(1):21-26.(in Chinese) [5] CONG Jing. A Study of Metro Shield Construction Safety Evaluation Based on Structure Entropy Weight Method[D]. Dalian:Dongbei University of Finance and Economics, 2016.(in Chinese) [6] LIU Dun-wen, JIA Hao-ran, ZHOU Chang-xiao, et al. Stability Evaluation of Excavation Face of Shield Tunnel Based on Cloud Model[J]. Journal of Beijing Jiaotong University, 2019, 43(3):43-49.(in Chinese) [7] YANG Jun, RUAN Yong-fen, CHEN Zhao-hui, et al. Evaluation of Shield Construction Safety Classes Based on Cloud Model[J]. Journal of Water Resources and Architectural Engineering, 2019, 17(3):150-154.(in Chinese) [8] WU Xian-guo, FENG Zong-bao, QIN Wen-wei, et al. Risk Assessment of Adjacent Buildings Induced by Shield Tunneling Construction Based on Matter-element Theory and Extension Theory[J]. Railway Standard Design, 2020, 64(4):104-110.(in Chinese) [9] LANG Yan-huai. Game Theory and Its Application[M]. Shanghai:Shanghai University of Finance&Economics Press, 2015.(in Chinese) [10] LIU Cheng-wei, WANG Juan, LI Xiao-peng, et al. Diversity of Interaction Intensity Enhances the Cooperation of Spatial Multi-Games on Interdependent Lattices[J]. Physics Letters A, 2020, 384(36):126928. [11] LIU Cheng-wei, WANG Juan, LI Xiao-peng, et al. The Link Weight Adjustment Considering Historical Strategy Promotes the Cooperation in the Spatial Prisoner'S Dilemma Game[J]. Physica A:Statistical Mechanics and Its Applications, 2020, 554:124691. [12] YE Yi-cheng, KE Li-hua, HUANG De-yu. System Comprehensive Evaluation Technology and Its Application[M]. Beijing:Metallurgical Industry Press, 2006.(in Chinese) [13] YANG Chun-yan, CAI Wen. Extenics[M]. Beijing:China Science Publishing&Media Ltd., 2014.(in Chinese) [14] LI De-yi, DU Juan. Uncertain Artificial Intelligence[M]. Beijing:National Defense Industry Press, 2005.(in Chinese) [15] WU An-ze. Stability Study of Side Slope Based on the Evaluation Model of Game Theory and Matter-Element Extension[D]. Chongqing:Chongqing Jiaotong University, 2015.(in Chinese) [16] LIU Guo-song. Application of Set Pair Analysis on Rock and Soil Slope Stability Evaluation Based on Combination Weighting Game Theory[D]. Hengyang:University of South China, 2014.(in Chinese) [17] WANG Quan, ZHENG Dong-jian. Fuzzy Extension Model of Large Culvert Safety Assessment Based on Game Theory and Its Application[J]. Water Resources and Power, 2015, 33(2):115-119, 130.(in Chinese) [18] CHEN Bo-wen, JIANG Bo, WANG Hui. Application of Game Theory and Cloud Model in Construction Safety Assessment of Power Transmission Project[J]. Industrial Safety and Environmental Protection, 2020, 46(5):83-86.(in Chinese) [19] SHEN Shi-wei, XU Jun-chen, DAI Shu-lin, et al. Extenics Evaluation of Joint Rock Tunnel Blasting Quality Based on Entropy Weighting Method[J]. China Civil Engineering Journal, 2013, 46(12):118-126.(in Chinese) [20] YANG Wen-ming, ZHENG Ming-xin, LI Zheng-yang, et al. Evaluation on Coal Measures Soil Slope Instability Risk Based on Combined Weighted Cloud Model[J]. Journal of Highway and Transportation Research and Development, 2022, 39(2):49-57.(in Chinese) [21] WANG Hua-lan, LIANG Yuan-sheng. Highway Pavement Performance Evaluation Model Based on Extension Cloud Theory[J]. Journal of China&Foreign Highway, 2015, 35(3):63-70.(in Chinese) [22] FAN Ru-guo, HAN Min-chun. Game Theory[M]. Wuhan:Wuhan University Press, 2006.(in Chinese) [23] CHEN Wen-qiang, GU Yu-lei, WANG Yong-jie, et al. Study on Optimal Pricing Model of Road Toll Based on Game Decision-making[J]. Journal of Highway and Transportation Research and Development, 2021, 38(5):152-158.(in Chinese) [24] WANG Wei, LIU Da-na, PENG Di. Safety Extension Evaluation of Deep Foundation Pit Excavation in Sandy Cobblestone Stratum Based on Entropy Method[J]. Journal of Southwest Jiaotong University, 2021, 56(4):785-791, 838.(in Chinese) [25] SAATY T L. Fundamentals of the Analytic Hierarchy Process[M]. Pittsburgh:RWS Publications, 2000. [26] GB50911-2013, Code for Monitoring Measurement of Urban Rail Transit Engineering[S].(in Chinese) [27] GB/T 50308-2017, Code for Urban Rail Transit Engineering Survey[S].(in Chinese) [28] GB50446-2017, Code for Construction and Acceptance of Shield Tunnelling Method[S].(in Chinese) [29] LANG Qiu-ling, WANG Wei, GAO Cheng-liang. Stability Evaluation of Deep Foundation Pit of Metro Based on Grey Correlation Analysis with Combined Weights[J]. Journal of Jilin University (Earth Science Edition), 2020, 50(6):1823-1832.(in Chinese) [30] JIANG Wei, YANG Lei, SHI Qiang, et al. Adaptability Evaluation of Shield Tunneling Based on Analytic Hierarchy Process and Fuzzy Synthetic Evaluation Method[J]. Science Technology and Engineering, 2021, 21(1):358-365.(in Chinese)
2024, Vol. 18 
